Table Of Contents

Previous topic

HRG with the Python API

Next topic

Directory Layout

Style Guide

Setting a coding style makes it easier to read and change code as everyone knows what to expect. The recommendations are based on established standards collected from a number of sources, individual experience, and local requirements/needs. There are several reasons for introducing a new guideline rather than just referring to others. Main reason is that these guides are far too general in their scope and that more specific rules (especially naming rules) need to be established.

The rules in this guide are not set in stone and variations that enhances readability allowed. The main goal of the recommendation is to improve readability and thereby the understanding and the maintainability and general quality of the code. It is impossible to cover all the specific cases in a general guide and the programmer should be flexible.

Naming Conventions

The reasons for using a naming convention include the following are to reduce the effort needed to understand the source code and to enhance source code appearance.

General naming rules

  • Use sensible, descriptive names. Do not use short cryptic names or names based on internal jokes. It shall be easy to type a name without looking up how it is spelt. Exception: Loop variables and variables with a small scope (less than 20 lines) may have short names to save space if the purpose of that variable is obvious.
  • Only use english names. It is confusing when mixing languages for names. English is the preferred language because of its spread in the software market and because most libraries used already use English.
  • Variables with a large scope shall have long names, variables with a small scope can have short names. Scratch variables used for temporary storage or indices are best kept short. A programmer reading such variables shall be able to assume that its value is not used outside a few lines of code. Common scratch variables for integers are i, j, k, m, n and for characters c and d.
  • Use name prefixes for identifiers declared in different modules. This avoids name clashes.
  • No names with leading and trailing underscores. Names with leading and trailing underscores are reserved for system purposes and should not be used for any user-created names.

Speect naming rules

The Speect library naming rules can be broken up into the following sections:

Data types

Data type Prefix Postfix Example
typedef s_   s_hash_element
struct s_   s_hash_element
union s_   s_hash_element
enum s_   s_hash_element
function pointer s_ _fp s_list_free_fp
object S   SMapHashTable
class S Class SMapHashTableClass

Class and object names shall begin with an upper case letter and words shall begin with an upper case letter (“CamelCase”).

Defines

Define Prefix Example
Macro S_ S_MALLOC
Constant S_ S_PI

Functions

Function Format Prefix Example
Speect private/static Underscore “_” between each word _s_ _s_load_voice_data_config
Private/static Underscore “_” between each word _ _find_name
Speect global/extern Underscore “_” between each word s_ s_list_index
Global/extern Underscore “_” between each word   name_finder
Speect class methods Start with object/class name, capitalize first character of each word S SItemLastDaughter

Class method names shall begin with the class’s object name, for example SItem, and the method shall begin with an upper case letter and words shall begin with an upper case letter (“CamelCase”), for example the “last daughter” method of SItem is named SItemLastDaughter.

Variables

Only Speect class and object variables have a naming convention:

Variable Format Postfix Example
Speect object CamelCase with first letter small caps   ebmlPlugin
Speect class CamelCase with first letter capitalized Class G2PRewritesClass

Indent Style

The indent style is the indentation style used on compound statements. A compound statement is a list of statements enclosed by braces. There are many common ways of formatting braces. The one used in the Speect library is known as the Allman style as defined by Wikipedia Indent Style. The style can be activated in Emacs cc-mode with:

(c-mode . "bsd")

and has a tabstop of 4 spaces. For example:

if (x == NULL)
{
    tmp--;
    if (tmp == 0)
    {
        cnt--;
        if (cnt == 0)
        {
            break;
        }
        else
        {
            cnt--;
        }
    }
}

File Organization

A file consists of various sections that should be separated by several blank lines. Although there is no maximum length limit for source files, files with more than about 1000 lines are cumbersome to deal with and should be the exception.

File and directory naming

Header file names

Avoid header filenames that are the same as C library filenames. The statement #include "math.h" should include the standard C library math header file and not a Speect header file.

Directory naming

Directory names should be short, concise and all small caps. The Directory Layout is a good example to follow.

Program files

Program files consists of header files and source code files. As a rule, header files should be used to give interface specifications and source files should implement that interface.

Nesting of header files

Header files should not be nested, in other words a header file’s included modules should describe other headers needed for that header so that it can be used on it’s own.

Included modules

All standard C library includes should be before any Speect library includes.

Inclusion guard

Header files should be guarded from duplicate inclusion by testing for the definition of a value, for example:

#ifndef _SPCT_OBJECT_H__
#define _SPCT_OBJECT_H__

where object.h is the header file’s name.

File Layout

The layout of the source and header files should follow the sequence of sections given below. Every section should be preceded with the appropiate comment block for that section as shown, of course not all files will require every section as given. All source and header files in Speect follow this layout, which makes the navigation of the library much easier as everything is consistent.

File header

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* $LICENSE INFO$                                                                   */
/*                                                                                  */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* AUTHOR  : $AUTHOR$                                                               */
/* DATE    : $DATE$                                                                 */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* $DESCRIPTION$                                                                    */
/*                                                                                  */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/

Where all the $tags$ are replaced with their appropriate entries.

Inclusion guard (header files only)

#ifndef _SPCT_OBJECT_H__
#define _SPCT_OBJECT_H__

Additional licenses

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* lib$additional$ $LICENSE INFO$                                                   */
/*                                                                                  */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/

Doxygen file description (header files only)

/**
 * Doxygen file description
 *
 */

Modules used (#include files)

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* Modules used                                                                     */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/

Begin external c declaration (header files only)

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* Begin external c declaration                                                     */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/
S_BEGIN_C_DECLS

Adds the S_BEGIN_C_DECLS so that the header file can be included in C++ projects.

Macros

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* Macros                                                                           */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/

Defines

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* Defines                                                                          */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/

Constants (source files only, no global constants)

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* Constants                                                                        */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/

Typedefs and Data types (structs and enums)

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* Typedefs and Data types                                                          */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/

External definitions

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* External definitions                                                             */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/

Static function prototypes (source files only)

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* Static function prototypes                                                       */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/

Function prototypes (header files only)

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* Function prototypes                                                              */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/

Function implementations (source files only)

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* Function implementations                                                         */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/

Static function implementations (source files only)

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* Static function implementations                                                  */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/

Static class function implementations (source files only)

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* Static class function implementations                                            */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/

Class initialization (source files only)

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* Class initialization                                                             */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/

End external c declaration (header files only)

/************************************************************************************/
/*                                                                                  */
/* End external c declaration                                                       */
/*                                                                                  */
/************************************************************************************/
S_END_C_DECLS

Adds the S_END_C_DECLS so that the header file can be included in C++ projects (closes S_BEGIN_C_DECLS).

End inclusion gaurd (header files only)

#endif /* _SPCT_OBJECT_H__ */

Comments

  • Only C style comments should be used, i.e.

    /* this is the right style of comment */
    // this is not right
    
  • Commenting out blocks of code must be done with the #if 0 and #endif pre-processor statements. Therefore, do not nest comments.

    #if 0 /* indicate the reason the code below is commented out */
    #define WKDS_SIZE  20  /* size */
    #define WKDS_LENGTH 10 /* length */
    #endif
    
  • Very short comments can appear on the same line as the code as long as it is visually seperated with tabs or spaces. If more than one short comment appears in a block of code they should all be tabbed to the same column.

    if (a == NULL)
    {
       b = TRUE;      /* special case  */
    }
    else
    {
       b = FALSE;     /* standard case */
    }
    
  • Use as much English as possible.

Declarations

Variables

  • The pointer qualifier, *, should be with the variable name rather than the variable type.

    char *s;  /* correct */
    char* s;  /* wrong   */
    
  • Declare only one variable per line and type.

    /* correct */
    char *s;
    char *t;
    
    /* wrong */
    char *s, *t;
    
  • For structure, union and enumaration declarations, each element should be alone on a line with a comment describing it.

    struct rectangle
    {
       int lngth;       /* rectangle length */
       int wdth;        /* rectangle width  */
    }
    
  • Any variable whose initial value is important should be explicitly initialized. Structure initializations should be fully parenthesized with braces. Constants used to intialize longs of floats should be explicitly long or float.

Functions

  • Each function in the header files should be fully documented in the doxygen Java style (all parameters and returns).

    /**
     * Set a character in a UTF-8 string and return the byte size.
     * of the character.
     * @param s The string.
     * @param c The UTF-8 character.
     * @return The byte size of the character.
     */
    int spct_utf8_setc(char *s, uint32 c);
    
  • Function return types and parameters must be explicitly defined and must not default to int.

  • Avoid local declarations that overide declarations at higher levels.

Whitespace

  • Use vertical and horizontal whitespace generously. Indentation and spacing should reflect the block structure of the code; e.g. there should be 2 blank lines between the end of one function and the beginning of the next.

  • A long string of conditionals should be split into seperate lines, for example:

    if ((temp != NULL) && (c1_to == NULL) || (count < 2)) /* not good */
    

    can be read better as

    /* good */
    
    if ((temp != NULL)
       && (c1_to == NULL)
       || (count < 2))
    
  • Simularly, long for loops should be split onto different lines:

    for (curr = *iterator, count = 1;
         curr != NULL;
         curr = next(curr), count++)
    
  • Add whitespaces between variables and operators.

    c=(lnw*3)/(tmp+4);         /* wrong */
    c = (lnw * 3) / (tmp + 4); /* good  */
    
  • Keywords that are followed by expressions in parentheses should be seperated from the left paranthesis by a blank (the sizeof operator is an exception). Blanks should appear after commas in argument lists to help seperate the arguments visually.

Statements

Simple Statements

  • The null body of a for or while loop should be alone on a line and commented so that it is clear that the null body is intentional and not missing code.

    while ((*dest)++ = (*src)++)
          ; /* VOID */
    
  • Do not default the test for NULL.

    if (f != NULL)
    

    is more readable than

    if (f)